Where to Eat on Anna Maria Island: 10 Best Restaurants

Local Favorites: Anna Maria Island Restaurants

Anna Maria Island, a charming barrier island on Florida’s Gulf Coast, is not only known for its pristine beaches and tranquil vibes but also its thriving food scene. From waterfront seafood shacks to elegant fine dining establishments, the island’s restaurants showcase the best of local flavors and fresh ingredients. Whether you’re craving a laid-back beachside bite or a gourmet culinary experience, Anna Maria Island offers something for every palate. Expect a mix of fresh Gulf seafood, farm-to-table dishes, and island-inspired cocktails served with a side of stunning sunsets. Dining on Anna Maria Island is as delightful as its laid-back lifestyle.

The Waterfront Restaurant – Anna Maria

‍‍Nestled just steps from Tampa Bay, The Waterfront Restaurant is a beloved local gem known for its elevated seafood dishes and welcoming charm. Founded by passionate restaurateurs committed to excellence, the restaurant emphasizes fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and thoughtful preparation. Its menu features a delightful mix of classic American favorites and coastal-inspired cuisine, making it a standout on Anna Maria Island. With indoor seating and a breezy outdoor patio offering stunning bay views, The Waterfront provides an atmosphere that is both relaxed and refined. Under the guidance of skilled chefs, this eatery continues to be a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Specialty: The Grouper Oscar is a show-stopping dish, showcasing perfectly cooked Gulf grouper topped with lump crab meat, tender asparagus, and a velvety hollandaise sauce. Paired with fresh seasonal sides, this meal exemplifies the restaurant's dedication to quality and flavor.

Location: 111 S Bay Blvd, Anna Maria, FL 34216. The restaurant is located near the Anna Maria City Pier and is easily accessible by car or bike. Ample parking is available nearby.

Local Tip: Visit during lunch to enjoy a quieter dining experience, and don’t miss pairing your meal with one of their signature craft cocktails or a refreshing glass of white wine.

Rating: 4.8/5

The Sandbar Restaurant – Anna Maria

‍Set directly on the beach, The Sandbar Restaurant is an iconic dining destination that combines breathtaking Gulf views with a commitment to sustainable and fresh cuisine. Founded by restaurateur Ed Chiles, the Sandbar emphasizes eco-friendly practices and partnerships with local fishermen and farmers to deliver dishes as authentic as the island itself. Guests can enjoy a laid-back yet elegant dining experience with their toes in the sand, surrounded by the soothing sounds of the ocean. Known for its friendly service and dedication to quality, The Sandbar is perfect for everything from casual lunches to romantic sunset dinners.

Specialty: The Lobster Mac and Cheese is a decadent blend of tender chunks of lobster, creamy cheeses, and al dente pasta, baked to golden perfection. It’s a comforting yet elevated dish that embodies the restaurant’s creative approach to classic comfort food.

Location: 100 Spring Ave, Anna Maria, FL 34216. Located on the northern tip of Anna Maria Island, directly on the Gulf beach. Accessible by car or bike, with parking available on-site.

Local Tip: Reserve a table for sunset to experience the stunning views and vibrant hues over the Gulf, making your meal as unforgettable as the scenery.

Rating: 4.7/5

Blue Marlin Seafood – Bradenton Beach

‍Housed in a beautifully restored 1920s cottage, Blue Marlin Seafood offers a cozy and rustic dining experience in the heart of Bradenton Beach. Owned and operated by Adam Ellis, who brings years of culinary passion to the table, this charming eatery is dedicated to showcasing the freshest seafood from the Gulf. The restaurant’s warm ambiance, with nautical-inspired decor and a quaint outdoor patio, makes it a popular spot for both locals and visitors. Blue Marlin prides itself on its friendly service, intimate atmosphere, and menu that celebrates the vibrant flavors of Florida’s coast.

Specialty: The Cortez Boil is a seafood lover’s delight, featuring a hearty mix of Gulf shrimp, crab, clams, mussels, corn, and potatoes, all simmered in a savory, seasoned broth that’s packed with flavor.

Location: 121 Bridge St, Bradenton Beach, FL 34217. Situated near the Bridge Street Pier, the restaurant is easily accessible by car, bike, or even the island trolley, with nearby parking available.

Local Tip: Stop by the Trap Yard behind the restaurant for live music, casual drinks, and a lively atmosphere to round out your evening on the island.

Rating: 4.7/5

Beach Bistro – Holmes Beach

‍Beach Bistro is a celebrated fine dining restaurant that has set the standard for luxury on Anna Maria Island for over 30 years. Founded by Sean Murphy, whose dedication to culinary excellence has earned national acclaim, Beach Bistro offers a romantic beachfront setting with stunning Gulf views. The restaurant prides itself on using only the finest ingredients, including fresh local seafood, domestic prime meats, and hand-selected wines from around the world. With its cozy, intimate atmosphere and award-winning dishes, Beach Bistro delivers an unparalleled dining experience that’s perfect for special occasions or a memorable night out.

Specialty: The Lobster and Gulf Shrimp Pappardelle is a decadent dish featuring tender lobster and shrimp, house-made pappardelle pasta, and a rich lobster butter sauce. This indulgent meal exemplifies the Bistro’s commitment to luxurious flavors.

Location: 6600 Gulf Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217. Located directly on the beach, just a short drive from Manatee Avenue. Valet parking is available for guests.

Local Tip: Arrive early for a pre-dinner cocktail on the beach and reserve a window-side table for an unobstructed view of the Gulf at sunset.

Rating: 4.9/5

The Feast – Holmes Beach

‍Located in the heart of Holmes Beach, The Feast is a welcoming, casual dining spot known for its diverse menu that caters to every palate. Owned by a local culinary team passionate about great food, The Feast offers a variety of dishes ranging from fresh seafood and hearty pastas to gourmet pizzas and crisp salads. With a relaxed indoor atmosphere and a shaded outdoor patio, it’s a versatile option for families, groups, or couples looking for a satisfying meal in a friendly setting.

Specialty: The Blackened Shrimp Tacos are a standout, served with tangy mango salsa, crisp slaw, and a zesty chipotle cream sauce, delivering a perfect balance of bold flavors and island freshness.

Location: 5406 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217. Situated in the Island Shopping Center, the restaurant is easy to find and offers ample parking.

Local Tip: Pair your meal with one of their signature tropical cocktails, and don’t miss their freshly baked key lime pie for dessert—it’s a local favorite.

Rating: 4.6/5

The Ugly Grouper – Holmes Beach

‍Known for its vibrant atmosphere and creative menu, The Ugly Grouper is a lively, family-friendly restaurant that embodies the fun and relaxed spirit of Anna Maria Island. Its spacious outdoor dining area, adorned with quirky art and plenty of shade, is a popular spot for both locals and tourists. The restaurant serves up fresh, Gulf-inspired dishes alongside classic American fare, with live music adding to the festive vibe. Owned by a team dedicated to delivering great food and fun, The Ugly Grouper is a go-to for casual island dining.

Specialty: The Grouper Sandwich, featuring grilled or blackened grouper served on a toasted brioche bun with house-made tartar sauce, is a must-try and showcases the island’s fresh seafood.

Location: 5704 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217. Easily accessible by car or golf cart, with convenient on-site parking.

Local Tip: Check their live music schedule for a dinner experience filled with island tunes, and try their signature Grouper Bites for a shareable appetizer packed with flavor.

Rating: 4.6/5

Rod and Reel Pier – Anna Maria

‍Perched at the northern tip of Anna Maria Island, Rod and Reel Pier is a charming, rustic eatery that has been a local favorite since 1947. This unassuming two-story restaurant extends over the water, offering diners stunning views of Tampa Bay while they enjoy freshly prepared seafood. Known for its laid-back vibe, friendly staff, and unbeatable location, Rod and Reel Pier is the perfect spot for a casual meal with an authentic island feel. Owned by locals who are passionate about preserving its iconic status, this pier-side gem captures the heart of Anna Maria’s dining culture.

Specialty: The Grouper Reuben is a creative take on the classic sandwich, featuring flaky, grilled grouper, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing on toasted rye bread. It’s a flavorful fusion of seafood and comfort food.

Location: 875 N Shore Dr, Anna Maria, FL 34216. Situated on the northernmost point of the island, accessible by car or bike with parking available near the pier.

Local Tip: Arrive early for breakfast to enjoy their signature pancakes while watching the sunrise over Tampa Bay—it’s a serene way to start your day on the island.

Rating: 4.7/5

Anna Maria Island Beach Café – Holmes Beach

‍Located directly on the sands of Manatee Public Beach, Anna Maria Island Beach Café offers a quintessential Florida dining experience. Known for its relaxed atmosphere and affordable prices, the café serves up classic beachside fare, including burgers, seafood, and tropical drinks. This family-friendly spot is ideal for casual meals, and the expansive outdoor seating allows diners to enjoy the sea breeze and Gulf views. Owned by a team dedicated to creating a welcoming beach atmosphere, the café is a staple for both locals and visitors seeking a laid-back meal.

Specialty: The All-You-Can-Eat Pancakes, served with syrup, butter, and optional add-ons like fresh fruit or chocolate chips, are a breakfast favorite that perfectly complements the beachfront setting.

Location: 4000 Gulf Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217. Located at Manatee Public Beach, with plenty of on-site parking and easy access from Gulf Drive.

Local Tip: Visit during live music nights for a fun, casual dinner by the beach, complete with dancing and family-friendly entertainment.

Rating: 4.5/5

Ginny's & Jane E's Café and Gift Store – Anna Maria

‍Ginny’s & Jane E’s is a quirky and charming café nestled in the heart of Anna Maria Island. Located inside a vintage-style general store, this unique spot offers hearty breakfast dishes, fresh sandwiches, and irresistible baked goods. The café’s eclectic decor, featuring local art and antiques, creates a cozy and whimsical atmosphere. Owned by locals who emphasize community and creativity, Ginny’s & Jane E’s is not just a place to eat—it’s a destination for discovering one-of-a-kind gifts and experiencing the island’s friendly charm.

Specialty: The Cinnamon Roll, made fresh daily and topped with a generous layer of cream cheese frosting, is a must-try indulgence that’s both decadent and satisfying.

Location: 9807 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria, FL 34216. Conveniently located near Pine Avenue, with on-site parking available for guests.

Local Tip: Arrive early for the best selection of baked goods, and enjoy your meal on the outdoor patio for a peaceful start to your morning.

Rating: 4.6/5

Tide Tables – Cortez

‍Tide Tables is a hidden gem located just off Anna Maria Island in the historic fishing village of Cortez. This waterfront restaurant offers fresh, no-frills seafood in a relaxed dockside setting. With its friendly staff, casual vibe, and focus on simple, flavorful dishes, Tide Tables captures the essence of coastal Florida dining. Owned and operated by locals who are passionate about sustainable seafood, this eatery is a favorite for those seeking an authentic taste of the Gulf.

Specialty: The Fish Tacos, made with blackened mahi-mahi, tangy slaw, and a zesty lime crema, deliver a perfect blend of spice, freshness, and satisfying texture.

Location: 12507 Cortez Rd W, Cortez, FL 34215. Situated just across the Cortez Bridge from Anna Maria Island, with ample parking available on-site.

Local Tip: Visit during lunchtime to watch the fishing boats unload their catch, and don’t miss pairing your meal with a cold local craft beer.

Rating: 4.7/5

Anna Maria Island’s dining scene is a vibrant blend of fresh seafood, waterfront views, and warm island hospitality. From cozy cafes to elegant beachfront restaurants, every meal on the island feels like a celebration of coastal living. Whether you’re indulging in a gourmet dish at Beach Bistro or enjoying casual fish tacos at Tide Tables, the island’s restaurants offer a unique experience for every palate.